|
Imported Fish
Move In on Fin Ordinaire
June 25, 2003
New York Times
By FLORENCE FABRICANT
Take another look at that fish on your plate. Chances are
very good that it is a world traveler, and just got off a
plane.
At one Greek restaurant in TriBeCa, diners can choose among
unusual varieties fresh from the Mediterranean. The menu lists
barbouni, a small, intensely flavored red fish also known
as rouget or red mullet; lavraki, a sleek, mild-tasting flaky
bass sometimes called branzino or loup de mer; and tsipoura
or dorado, a popular dish in Italian restaurants, where it
is known as orata and is a favorite for grilling.
Barramundi, a rich-flavored reef fish from Australia that
some chefs compare with Chilean sea bass, and bluenose from
New Zealand, a big variety with firm flesh, are also showing
up on menus. In markets, they are giving flounder a run for
the money.
Most surprising about these fish from distant ports is that
they arrive, fresh and glistening, just two or three days
out of the water. It can sometimes take longer to get local
fish from net to plate.
The days when Dover sole from the English Channel impressed
diners are clearly over. Chefs have other fish to fry, sauté,
grill and roast.
"Efficiencies in air freight make it possible to put fresh
fish from anywhere in the world on the plate," said Howard
M. Johnson, a consultant to the seafood industry from Jacksonville,
Ore. "And it's increasingly important, since we've seen reductions
in many of our native fisheries, like cod, grouper and rockfish."
Today, 76 percent of all seafood consumed in the United States
is imported, according to the National Marine Fisheries Service,
a government agency; only Japan imports more fish. From 1992
though 2001, imports to the United States increased from less
than $6 billion to nearly $10 billion. Shrimp account for
more than half the total, and salmon imports are also significant.
But the American market for other finfish from afar is growing
rapidly.
Some fish, like barramundi or bluenose, are destined for
high-end restaurants and markets. The fast-food industry,
meanwhile, is buying hoki, a bland-tasting but abundant fish
from New Zealand.
Australia has doubled the amount of fish it sends to these
shores in the last 10 years to 16 million pounds, said Beth
Goslin, the business development manager for the Australian
Trade Commission. This increase in imports reflects the growth
in fish consumption in the United States - from less than
10 pounds a person 50 years ago to more than 20 pounds now.
Just a year ago, Peter Jarvis, the owner of Triar Seafood,
a fish importer in Hollywood, Fla., began bringing in barramundi,
a wild fish that is also farmed. He started with a weekly
300 pounds of the farmed variety and is now up to 6,000 pounds
a week.
The Republic of Cyprus began exporting farmed fish, mostly
orata and branzino, to the United States in 1996, and since
then its shipments have increased from $300,000 to $1.6 million
a year. "We send it off on Sunday and it's in the restaurant
kitchen by Monday," said Dennis Droushiotis, the trade commissioner
for Cyprus. The country's fish farms are state-of-the-art
facilities in deep, clean waters, Mr. Droushiotis said, adding,
"We're relatively new at this, and we can take advantage of
the latest technology."
Greece, where some 200 fish farms raise most of the branzino
and orata sold here, has become another important source.
Richard Martin, an owner of Wild Edibles, which has two fish
shops in Manhattan and also supplies restaurants, said the
change in his import business in the past five or so years
has been "tremendous."
"We imported almost nothing five years ago because most of
what was available was frozen," he said. "Now almost all of
it is flown in fresh, and imports account for at least 15
to 20 percent of our business."
Because of increased availability and competition, the price
for most imported fish has declined, making many varieties
comparable in price to domestic fish, even with the cost of
air freight factored in, said Joe Gurrera, the owner of the
five Citarella markets in New York and on Long Island. For
example, in his stores whole pink snapper from New Zealand
is $5.99 a pound, the same price as local porgies.
Except for varieties like rouget and sardines, the flesh
of these imports is white, the flavor quite mild and the texture
meaty enough. Many of the fishes weigh two pounds or less,
a convenient size for home and restaurant use. Their novelty,
of course, is another plus.
"I'm always looking for fish that's different," said Tom
Colicchio, an owner of Craft, who, when he can find it, has
taken to roasting Tasmanian sea trout. "It's rich, like arctic
char," he said. "And I can get it within 24 hours so it's
in great shape."
Not everyone is so smitten.
"Most of those farm-raised fish have no flavor," said Eric
Ripert, the chef and an owner of Le Bernardin. He does use
a few imports, like rouget from Spain or Brittany or hamachi,
from Japan. The mainstays of his menu, however, are the halibut
and sea bass found in American waters.
But severe declines in the fish populations off domestic
shores, largely because of overfishing, have made aquaculture
even more important. Some problems have come to light, however,
like the destruction of natural mangrove habitats by shrimp
farms and the farms' use of pesticides and antibiotics. Critics
of the farms say the booming Atlantic salmon industry pollutes
the water with fish waste and additives.
Mr. Johnson, the consultant from Oregon, said that the new
farms being established in many countries "have better practices,
and others are cleaning up their acts."
But some experts are not convinced.
"Fish farming is relatively new, and the regulations are
weak," said Michael Sutton, a program officer at the Packard
Foundation, a nonprofit organization in Los Altos, Calif.
"I might have more confidence in some of the developed countries.
Other countries have no controls." The foundation, which supports
ocean conservation, promotes education so consumers can make
informed choices.
In Australia, both wild fisheries and farms "have to answer
to seven different authorities, government and industry,"
said John Susman, the manager of Fishbizz, a consulting company
in New South Wales. "We've looked at where there have been
disasters and we're taking precautions."
Rachel Roper-Taulelei, a trade commissioner for New Zealand
who is based in Los Angeles, said that all fish imported from
her country are wild. "We bring in 51 kinds of fish, and we've
had a sustainable program in place since 1986," she said.
"Our scientists assess the populations and set quotas."
Bluenose, grouper, several snappers, dories and orange roughy
are among the fishes that New Zealand exports to the United
States, Ms. Roper-Taulelei said, adding that fish lovers should
begin to look for tarakihi, a "delicious white-fleshed fish."
American consumers, however, usually do not know where the
fish in their markets comes from. Department of Agriculture
regulations requiring labels in stores indicating country
of origin and information on whether seafood is wild or farm-raised
will not go into effect for a year.
As tempting as it may be for chefs and consumers to sear
a thick piece of barramundi or put a whole orata on the grill,
the availability of these novelties is no reason to ignore
the local seasonal catch.
Vikki N. Spruill, the president of SeaWeb, a nonprofit organization
in Washington that supports seafood conservation, said rebuilding
local fisheries should be a priority.
"Fish does rebound if it's well managed - striped bass is
a fabulous example," she said, "and that way we can become
less dependent on imports."
But these fish may be here to stay. |